Hey bradleyheathhays,
Good job finding that starter problem! I've had good luck with starters from places like O'Reilly's/AdvanceAuto etc. And when you do the work youself, it's less of a risk if you have to do it again in a few years compared to someone who has to pay a shop to do it, so go ahead and save some money.
I've also had good luck pulling used parts from yards, although fewer in my area are letting customers pull parts themselves these days. It's a good way to get original quality parts for cheap.
That '96 is the last year with the original AMC dash before Chrysler updated it, right? I've got a 2000 XJ that my father-in-law gave to me when the cylinder head cracked, he was fed up with it! I've had to fix a bunch of stuff on it, but the 4WD works great and I've been plowing with it the past 3 winters. I plan to put in a 2WD-LO kit from TeraFlex to make it easier to make tight turns in low range.
Do you have any off-road mods on yours?