I think I would try bridging the batt and starter terminals and see if it cranks. I bought a cheap solenoid for my atv which lasted less than a week. It clicked but, used aligator clips with voltmeter across batt/starter terminals. when I hit the start button sure enough, it read full battery voltage indicating open circuit between batt/starter terminals. So, I put the old solenoid back on and it started right up. I'll try to buy as much OEM parts as I can afford, after that. 🙂